×

Analyzing offside rules in Serie A

I’m thinking about an episode in Serie A where a referee mistakenly called offside on a goal kick, possibly in September 2021. The user seems frustrated with the refereeing quality. They might be prompting me to explain that offside can’t be given from a goal kick and to analyze the situation: why it’s a mistake, and the role of VAR. The key point is that VAR can only intervene for clear errors leading to goals, penalties, or red cards, but not in this instance since it was a restart.Clarifying VAR protocol in football

I’m considering VAR protocol, which can’t review situations like non-reviewable restarts, such as free kicks. An offside call is only reviewable if a goal is scored, not if the referee blows the whistle beforehand. In this case, the referee whistled offside from a goal kick, which by law can’t happen. If there's a significant law misapplication, like wrongfully awarding a free kick, a competition might allow for a replay. It’s intriguing how these situations play out in various leagues, like in the Bundesliga or Premier League.Explaining potential replays in Serie A

I’m thinking about a past incident in FIFA 2006 where a replay occurred due to a misapplied encroachment penalty in the Uzbekistan vs. Bahrain match. In Serie A, replays are typically rare, but if a law is misapplied, it could prompt one. Since the user mentioned a headline, I should ask if they’d like an explanation. I’ll clarify that offside can’t be called from a goal kick, which is a misstep. If the referee had realized immediately, they could restart with a dropped ball.Clarifying offside rules on goal kicks

I’m considering how a goal kick works. The ball is in play once it’s kicked and definitely moves. Only the goalkeeper or a teammate can be the kicker. Offside occurs when a player receives the ball from a teammate unless it’s from a goal kick. The rule specifies that there’s no offside if a player receives it directly from a goal kick, throw-in, or corner. So if a player is offside after a teammate touches the ball, that’s valid. This means the initial call would be incorrect if a player was offside directly from the goal kick.